Start here for information about Redeemer--whether you're new to Charleston, just visiting for the weekend, or looking for a new church family. We're glad you're thinking of … Read More
Mayor, community leaders rally at Redeemer Presbyterian Church
Sunday, July 22, 2012
Charleston Mayor Joe Riley (at podium) and dozens of Redeemer Presbyterian Church leaders and preservation and religious leaders gathered in Redeemer’s sanctuary Friday to ask for donations to help ensure the historic Greek Revival building remains a church.
If the current congregation inside the historic church at 43 Wentworth St. can raise the $1.6 million to buy the property, then it would get a conservation easement to ensure the church would never be converted into a home.
To contribute, go to holycitycharleston.org or mail a check to the Preservation Society of Charleston, P.O. Box 521, Charleston, SC 29402.
That’s what the Rev. Craig Bailey of Redeemer Presbyterian Church said Friday as he, Charleston Mayor Joe Riley and other preservation and religious leaders launched a fund drive.
The former St. Andrew’s Lutheran Church and its educational building were poised to be sold to a local businesswoman who planned to renovate them into residences and office space. Currently, Redeemer only leases the space.
When Charleston City Councilman Blake Hallman pushed to repeal a zoning variance, then the buyer, St. Andrew’s and others struck a compromise to postpone the sale and give Redeemer a few months to try to raise the $1.6 million sales price.
“Being the last congregation in this building is not a designation we desire,” Bailey said. “We don’t want to say we were the last congregation to sing ‘Silent Night’ here.”
Redeemer’s leaders earlier ruled out buying the property when its asking price was $8 million, then $4 million, but Bailey said the $1.6 million figure might be within reach of his young congregation — especially with help from the larger community.
Riley urged others to support the effort vocally and financially.
“We have to seize this opportunity and save this church,” he said, adding it could be seen as a watershed moment in the city’s long preservation history.
Cress Darwin, pastor of Second Presbyterian Church less than a mile up Meeting Street, said the church at 43 Wentworth St. is far from the only case where a historic congregation in peninsular Charleston has struggled, but they can be saved with help from one another.
“The loss of a church is not just unfortunate,” he said. “The loss of a church has a profound impact on the fabric and integrity of a community.”
The Historic Charleston Foundation pledged $2,500 to kick-start the fund drive, and City Councilman Marvin Wagner, who grew up in the church, pledged another $1,000.
While that’s only a small fraction of the goal, organizers hope to find broad-based support in the community among those interested.
Evan Thompson of Charleston’s Preservation Society, which is collecting the donations, said: “It’s not just what buildings look like on the outside that’s important, but what they’re like on the inside. It’s just like people.”
John Hildreth, director of the National Trust’s Southern Office in Charleston, said the issue of saving historic downtown churches has come up in many other U.S. cities, such as Chicago, Los Angeles, New Orleans and Boston.
“What’s different is we now have leadership here that wasn’t evident in other cities,” he said.
The Greek Revival building was built as a Methodist church around 1840, but it merged with a Lutheran congregation and changed to that denomination shortly after the Civil War. St. Andrew’s congregation moved to West Ashley around 2006 and since has leased the building to Redeemer Presbyterian.
Written by Robert Behre of The Post and Courier. Reach him at 843-937-5771.
The prayer of a righteous person is powerful and effective. James 5:16
Great news from the City Council meeting this evening! We did not have to bring the church-zoning issue to a vote, because Nancy Snowden agreed to step back to give us some time to raise funds to purchase the church. And Mayor Riley will be helping–which is huge! He spoke eloquently about the church and how important it is to keep it in its current use for generations to come.
The agreement to delay the vote came late today, and we tried to catch you before you were heading to City Hall, but I know we missed some of you. Sorry.
We expect to kick off the city-wide fundraising campaign later this week. And will be working out the timeframe in which to raise funds (probably 90 days) with the Lutherans. With the Mayor’s help, we can succeed!
Thank you all for your fervent prayers, emails, and calls to our city’s leaders. They made all the difference!
From today’s Post and Courier:
Church a comfort
My father recently passed away with cancer. He successfully ran his own business for many years and had a wife and six children at home when he was diagnosed.
When he became too sick to work, there were no pay- checks and no unemployment benefits because he was self-employed. He was sick for a long time, and was in and out of the hospital.
It has been a difficult time for my family emotionally and financially, but several area churches stepped in to help.
Redeemer Presbyterian Church was one of them. They just showed up at our door with bags full of groceries and encouraging words. That continued week after week after week.
My family never attended Redeemer Presbyterian, nor did we have friends there.
People should know about the good that this church does in the community. Redeemers’ place of worship at 43 Wentworth St. may soon be sold to become Nancy Snowden’s house.
I hope Charleston’s leaders take the public good done by this church into account and decide not to allow this downtown church to be used for commercial and residential purposes.
Surely there are plenty of properties available for those uses other than a church with an active congregation that has such a heart for our city and its people.
Willow Lake Drive
From today’s Post and Courier:
The building at 43 Wentworth St. was built as a church, and should remain so absent a compelling reason for a change. Its future as such is in serious jeopardy following a decision by the city of Charleston Board of Zoning Appeals to grant a variance so it can be used for residential and office purposes.
The decision should be reversed by Charleston City Council, which has the authority to overturn the BZA in this instance.
Councilman Blake Hallman plans to make a motion to that effect at Tuesday’s City Council meeting. He should have the support of his colleagues. Mr. Hallman outlines his opposition to plans for the building in a column on our Commentary page.
The fact that the building is currently occupied by another congregation should bolster the resolve to ensure that this Ansonborough landmark retains its historic use.
The building is owned by a Lutheran church that has moved its congregation elsewhere. In recent years, it has served as home to Redeemer Presbyterian Church, which rents the property, but wants to remain there permanently. While it doesn’t have the resources to buy the structure at present, its membership has expressed a strong desire to undertake a fund-raising campaign.
Why not give them an opportunity to do so?
If Redeemer is successful, the church building could retain its historic use in this historic neighborhood. The structure wouldn’t have to be compromised for another purpose.
And the current congregation would get to stay in a setting to which its members have grown greatly attached.
The decision to allow the building to be used for another purpose has resulted in a cascade of letters to the editor in opposition.
Some critics cite the shortcomings of the BZA action, saying that the proposal didn’t meet the hardship threshold required for the variance. Others decry the decision to sell the building when the current tenant wants to maintain it for its historic use.
Allowing this church to be altered for residential and commercial space shouldn’t be allowed to happen, certainly not when there’s every likelihood that the church can continue to be used for its original purpose.
From today’s Post and Courier:
Zoning variance for turning church into a residence would set a dangerous precedent
The City of Charleston’s Board of Zoning Appeals recently granted a variance to allow St. Andrew’s Lutheran Church, a beautiful pre-Civil War Greek revival style church in the heart of downtown at 43 Wentworth St., to be converted into three residences and two businesses.
It is a precedent-setting issue that could ultimately change the social fabric of our city. I am actively working with the mayor and other City Council members to resolve it.
Although I appreciate the hard work the committee does as well as the scrutiny under which they work, many of us on council do not agree with this decision. It is my firm belief that this variance sets a damaging precedent.
Allowing the unnecessary conversion of historic churches to higher dollar uses for businesses and multi-family housing may ultimately result in pricing new churches out of downtown Charleston. Variances like this could become the easy default for aging or dwindling congregations. Then Charleston would lose downtown churches one by one over time, instead of having younger congregations come in to replace the declining ones, as has been the case for nearly two centuries. Sometimes a variance may be appropriate, but not in this case where a beautiful church without any major structural problems is filled with eager worshipers.
The prospective buyer, interested in converting the church, applied for and received a zoning variance. The city’s ordinance allows a variance to be granted only in cases where the current zoning creates an unnecessary hardship which effectively prohibits or unreasonably restricts the utilization of the property.
Certainly, the current zoning is not creating a hardship that prevents utilization of the property since an active young Presbyterian congregation has been worshiping there for over five years and has attempted to purchase the church. No good reason is apparent why this 173-year-old sanctuary, with its beautiful stained glass windows, balconies, historic pipe organ and cemetery cannot continue to be a Gospel presence for generations to come.
It is my firm belief that City Council must obey the spirit and the letter of the variance law. Maximizing profit from a church sale to build a large suburban church, or increasing a property’s value for a potential investor does not rise to the level of an “unnecessary hardship” for purposes of granting a variance.
This zoning variance would increase the value of the property; the higher price would make it more difficult to continue its current and historical use and even more difficult to attract a new congregation as our historic churches have done numerous times in the past.
I did not agree with the explanation of the “unnecessary hardship” by the Board of Zoning Appeals, either. The board reasoned that the church buildings are larger than most homes and are more like other businesses. The board indicated that “as for office use, that exists now on the ground floor on the Parish house.”
Many other church buildings downtown are larger than residences, and they have pastor’s offices in them, too. One can easily extrapolate the damaging precedent that would be set here, if this variance is allowed to stand. That is why I am bringing it before City Council so we can consider vetoing it.
This variance would ultimately result in new congregations being priced out of the market downtown. Over time, our historic churches would fall, one after another into business and condominium use. It is not in the Holy City’s best interest to allow its historic churches to be rezoned when feasible alternatives exist to maintain them in their current and historical uses and keep them as centers of worship and community activity.
It would be a shame to see our historic churches privatized, looking more like the fake facades of a movie set, instead of vibrant community centers benefitting Charlestonians for generations to come.
During the last two centuries, Charleston’s churches, like others around our nation, have passed from congregation to congregation, often changing denominations along the way. When congregations dwindled, church buildings were given or sold at modest prices to new congregations.
Numerous examples exist, including St. Andrew’s Lutheran Church, which began as a Methodist church. As a child, I attended Westminster Presbyterian Church on Rutledge Avenue with my grandmother. As their congregation dwindled in size, they merged with a West Ashley congregation, but only after selling the church to a Baptist congregation. Grandmother’s old church is now the Jerusalem Baptist Church, an active church which, under the leadership of Pastor Salley, has over 14 groups that actively minister to its congregation as well as its community.
The disagreement over the interpretation of this variance presents us with a “win-win” opportunity. The first “win” is to show that government can indeed be responsive to the needs of the community. The second “win” is one that allows the Holy Spirit Lutheran congregation, the owners of the church at 43 Wentworth, to receive fair market value for their property by passing the church along with the same generous spirit in which it was received, so that the rich heritage of worship and service to the community can be continued.
Seldom do we have such opportunities; they should not be wasted.
Blake Hallman is a Charleston city councilman. He received the 2006 Preservationist of the Year award from the Civil War Preservation Trust for his work in protecting Morris Island.
From today’s Post and Courier:
Fans of old church put faith in Holy City
Those hoping to preserve 43 Wentworth St. as a church are throwing a Hail Mary pass to Charleston City Council.
The Wentworth Street Methodist Protestant Church was built on this site in 1834 and rebuilt after the 1838 fire in a Greek Revival style. It suffered from shelling during the Civil War and became a Lutheran congregation after it merged with Zion Evangelical Lutheran Church, which had been on Morris Street. A Sunday school building was built next door in 1894. The church’s interior was redecorated extensively in 1908 and again in the late 1930s.
—From Jonathon Poston’s “The Buildings of Charleston”
And they just might complete it.
Council members could vote Tuesday on overturning a Board of Zoning Appeals decision that allowed the church to be converted into a residence.
City Councilman Blake Hallman said Friday he is concerned that the zoning board’s decision sets a bad precedent that, if left unchallenged, could erode the number of historic churches still in use in the Holy City.
“I’ve talked to enough (City Council colleagues) to expect that this variance will not stand,” he added.
The temple-style church building was built around 1840 as a Methodist church, but it merged with a Lutheran congregation in 1866.
St. Andrews Lutheran Church worshipped in the building until 2006, when it merged with another Lutheran congregation to form the new Holy Spirit Lutheran Church in West Ashley. That church then leased its Wentworth property to Redeemer Presbyterian Church, which still uses the property, said the Rev. Craig Bailey of Redeemer.
But the Wentworth property also has been for sale for years, and businesswoman Nancy Snowden has plans to buy the 6,445-square-foot sanctuary, neighboring 12,441-square-foot fellowship hall and a 15-space parking lot.
Last month, she received a variance from the city’s Board of Zoning Appeals to turn the sanctuary into a home and to convert the fellowship building into two housing units and office space.
That board’s decisions are subject to review by City Council, which normally doesn’t reconsider them but apparently will in this case.
Hallman said he will argue the church property doesn’t have any unusual hardship or extraordinary conditions that would merit a variance.
“It’s an active, viable property,” he said. “I think that it (the variance) sets a very onerous precedent for future churches.”
Since the board’s decision, a growing number of people have questioned what is going on — and whether there’s some way this building can remain as a church. These voices include those currently worshipping there.
Bailey and Nancy Vinson, a Redeemer member, said their congregation started in the Terrace Theatre on James Island in 1999 and welcomed the opportunity to move downtown and be closer to the homeless shelter, public schools and other opportunities for ministry.
Redeemer has paid the cost of utilities and half the insurance bill to lease the property, and it always understood it might have to move one day.
But Bailey said when Redeemer realized the church’s price was dropping, it began wondering if it could stay. He said Redeemer has made its own offer for the property —an offer it believed to be equal to Snowden’s, except that the church asked for more time to arrange financing if its contract was accepted. “All we know is they rejected our offer without comment,” he said.
Snowden previously declined to verify the sales price, and neither she nor officials with Holy Spirit Lutheran Church returned messages left Friday.
Even if the Lutheran church did not want to accept Redeemer’s offer, Vinson wondered whether other congregations might be interested in buying it at a comparable price. “We wouldn’t bat an eye or open our mouths if they were selling it to another church,” she added.
While some Lowcountry churches have been converted to homes or public spaces, the idea can trigger a lot of emotion.
A proposal to convert the New Tabernacle Fourth Baptist Church at Elizabeth and Charlotte streets into a theater was turned down a few years ago after neighbors and others objected.
Still, many congregations in historic church buildings downtown are grappling with the twin challenges of dwindling congregations and rising maintenance costs.
Robert Gurley of the Preservation Society of Charleston said that group is mostly concerned about the variance allowing an office use in the fellowship building next door.
Gurley said the society would like to see a church remain a church, “but what we don’t want to see happen is churches falling down.”
Hallman said if the 43 Wentworth building were vacant, then there would be a more compelling case to allow a new use on the site.
He noted churches often go through periods of prosperity and decline, and the city should do what it can to help them survive during their lowest points.
Reach Robert Behre at 937-5771.
July 13, 2012
Buying a church
As an 11th generation Charlestonian I am appalled at the ease of buying a historic downtown church and turning it into a private residence.
Not an abandoned, dilapidated church, but a thriving, productive church that benefits the city in remarkable ways.
I refuse to be silent, as my relatives were when the Charleston Hotel was demolished in 1960, and the Orphan House Chapel was torn down in the mid ’50s to make a parking lot.
Where is the Lutheran Synod? Where is Mayor Joe Riley?
My ancestors are spinning in their graves.
Deanne Clark Highway 17 North Mount Pleasant
July 12, 2012
As a former College of Charleston student, walking was a way of life. I walked to classes, restaurants, shops, and grocery stores.
Without a car several semesters, I was at the mercy of roommates and friends to transport me to church in the suburbs on Sundays.
A decade ago the churches in the suburbs were the only ones actively reaching out to college students. How wonderful to have had a young, vibrant congregation like Redeemer Presbyterian downtown within a short walk of the college.
Redeemer takes care of college students, offering “adoptive” families for students who want a listening ear, a home-cooked meal, or a comfortable place to do laundry.
Redeemer is also the church home for several campus-ministry staff, bringing many students through its doors on Sundays and during the week.
College students are an important part of our city, and churches that minister to our students should be encouraged.
If our city leaders don’t preserve and protect growing, worshiping downtown congregations, then college students without cars might determine it’s far easier to forego their Sunday habit.
Gray Morgan Gemstone Boulevard Hanahan
Great legal editorial in the paper today by a Jewish attorney documenting how the variance granting business and multifamily residential uses of our church is UNLAWFUL.
‘Use-variance’ shouldn’t apply in this case
Post and Courier, Wednesday, July 11, 2012
The Board of Zoning Appeals granted a “use-variance” for the historic church building at 43 Wentworth Street at the request of a prospective purchaser.
It allows the church to be converted into multiple residential and office uses. Many have voiced opposition to this decision, motivating me to comment on how it violates longstanding legal precedent.
The law allows a variance (basically, an exception) from zoning regulations if they cause an “unnecessary hardship.”
More than half a century ago, the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that granting a variance is an “exceptional power which should be sparingly exercised,” and the court has since adopted rules limiting variances.
One such rule disqualifies a property owner if he purchased the property after the complained-of zoning was in effect.
This rule makes sense. One cannot claim unnecessary hardship if the claimed hardship is self-created and could have been avoided.
Forty-three Wentworth Street’s use-variance violates this rule. The current owner acquired the property in 2009. Used as a church for generations, the property’s zoning prohibited more intensive residential and office uses.
It makes no difference that a prospective buyer is the applicant since the zoning exists before her purchase as well.
The unnecessary hardship is self-created and can be avoided.
The owner does not have to sell to someone intending to convert the church to several residences and businesses.
Nothing in the board’s decision states that this is the only marketable use for the property.
In fact, the church worshiping there now may be interested in purchasing and carrying on church activities for years to come.
There are several other reasons, in my view, why the board’s decision was incorrect, but space is limited.
Fortunately, the City Council has the power to reverse the board’s decision on July 17.
Ross Appel Ashley Avenue Charleston
July 6, 2012
I am appalled by the Board of Zoning Appeals decision to permit the sale of St. Andrews Lutheran Church at 143 Went-worth St.
The beautiful altar with the painting of the risen Christ above, the mahogany pews, the small graveyard with tombs dating back 150 years, including the graves of the daughters of Admiral de Grasse, this is to be a residence? I urge the BZA to rescind its vote.
Kathryn K. Matthew St. Michaels Alley Charleston